Skip to content
Chegu Khairi

Pengamiran · Tingkatan 5

Dua Kesilapan dalam Satu Soalan Kamiran Tentu

Two Mistakes in One Definite Integral

Two Mistakes in One Definite Integral

Kesilapan ini kami jumpa berulang kali semasa menanda kertas pelajar. Mari lihat di mana ia berlaku.

We see this mistake again and again when marking pupils' papers. Here is where it happens.

Soalan

The question

5 (a) Jika ∫ (3x + 2)ⁿ dx = a(3x + 2)⁻² + c, cari nilai a dan nilai n. (b) Diberi bahawa d/dx ( 2x/(2x² + 3) ) = g(x), cari nilai ∫₀² [ (g(x))/2 - 2x ] dx.
Soalan seperti dicetak dalam kertas

Cara betul, langkah demi langkah. Pecahkan kamiran dan keluarkan 1/2 daripada sebutan g(x) sahaja: ∫₀² [(g(x))/2 - 2x] dx = 1/2∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx. Oleh kerana d/dx(2x/(2x²+3)) = g(x), maka ∫ g(x) dx = 2x/(2x²+3) + c. Kamirkan 2x untuk mendapat x²: 1/2[2x/(2x²+3)]₀² - [x²]₀². Gantikan had atas 2 dan had bawah 0: 1/2(4/11 - 0) - (4 - 0). Darab dahulu, baru tolak: 2/11 - 4 = -42/11.

The correct method, step by step. Split the integral and take the 1/2 out of the g(x) term only: ∫₀² [(g(x))/2 - 2x] dx = 1/2∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx. Since d/dx(2x/(2x²+3)) = g(x), it follows that ∫ g(x) dx = 2x/(2x²+3) + c. Integrate 2x to get x²: 1/2[2x/(2x²+3)]₀² - [x²]₀². Substitute the upper limit 2 and the lower limit 0: 1/2(4/11 - 0) - (4 - 0). Multiply first, then subtract: 2/11 - 4 = -42/11.

Tonton penjelasannya

Watch the explanation

Dua pelajar, dua kesilapan berbeza dalam satu soalan pengamiran: Bahagian 1 dan Bahagian 2.

99 saat · 99 seconds

Kertas sebenar, sudah ditanda

The marked scripts

The factor of 1/2 is incorrectly applied to the entire expression instead of only to ∫ g(x) dx.
Pendaraban 1/2 salah diperluaskan kepada keseluruhan ungkapan dan bukannya pada ∫ g(x) dx sahaja. The factor of 1/2 is incorrectly applied to the entire expression instead of only to ∫ g(x) dx.
The integration of ∫ 2x dx is incorrectly written as [2x]₀² instead of [x²]₀².
Pengamiran ∫ 2x dx ditulis secara tidak betul sebagai [2x]₀² berbanding [x²]₀². The integration of ∫ 2x dx is incorrectly written as [2x]₀² instead of [x²]₀².

Yang salah

What went wrong

∫₀² ( (g(x))/2 - 2x ) dx
= 1/2 ∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx
= 1/2 [ 2x/(2x²+3) ]₀² - [2x]₀²
= 1/2 [ 4/11 - 0 ] - [2(2) - 2(0)]
= 2/11 - 4
= -42/11

Yang betul

The correct working

∫₀² ( (g(x))/2 - 2x ) dx
= 1/2 ∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx
= 1/2 [ 2x/(2x²+3) ]₀² - [x²]₀²
= 1/2 [ (2(2))/(2(2)²+3) - 0 ] - [2² - 0²]
= 1/2 ( 4/11 ) - 4
= -42/11

Kenapa ramai buat silap ini

Why this happens

Dua pelajar hilang markah dalam soalan ini, dengan dua kesilapan yang berbeza. Kedua-duanya ada dalam video: Bahagian 1 untuk kesilapan pertama, Bahagian 2 untuk kesilapan kedua. Kesilapan 1 (Bahagian 1): 2x tidak dikamirkan. Selepas memecahkan kamiran kepada 1/2∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx, pelajar pertama menulis -[2x]₀². Itu bukan kamiran bagi 2x — ungkapan 2x hanya disalin ke dalam kurungan. Kamiran yang betul ialah ∫ 2x dx = x² + c, jadi sebutan kedua sepatutnya -[x²]₀². Secara kebetulan, 2(2) - 2(0) = 4 dan 2² - 0² = 4, maka jawapan akhir pelajar ini tetap -42/11. Tetapi pemeriksa menyemak setiap langkah, bukan hanya jawapan: langkah pengamiran itu salah, dan markahnya hilang walaupun jawapan akhir sama. Kesilapan 2 (Bahagian 2): pemalar 1/2 didarab dengan semua sebutan. Pelajar kedua mengamirkan dengan betul, tetapi semasa menggantikan had, menulis 1/2[4/11 - 4] = 1/2(-40/11) = -20/11. Pemalar 1/2 datang daripada (g(x))/2, jadi ia hanya milik ∫₀² g(x) dx. Ia tidak boleh mendarab -4, kerana -4 datang daripada ∫₀² 2x dx yang tidak pernah dibahagi dua. Selepas itu, pelajar ini menggantikan -20/11 ke dalam kamiran asal sebagai g(x) dan mengamirkan sekali lagi, lalu mendapat -64/11. Kamiran tentu sudah selesai sebaik sahaja had digantikan: nombor yang diperoleh ialah jawapan, bukan fungsi untuk dikamirkan semula.

Two pupils lost marks on this question, with two different mistakes. Both are in the video: Part 1 covers the first mistake, Part 2 the second. Mistake 1 (Part 1): 2x was not integrated. After splitting the integral into 1/2∫₀² g(x) dx - ∫₀² 2x dx, the first pupil wrote -[2x]₀². That is not the integral of 2x — the expression 2x was simply copied into the brackets. The correct integral is ∫ 2x dx = x² + c, so the second term should be -[x²]₀². By coincidence, 2(2) - 2(0) = 4 and 2² - 0² = 4, so this pupil still reached the final answer -42/11. But examiners mark every step, not only the answer: the integration step was wrong, and its mark is lost even though the final answer matches. Mistake 2 (Part 2): the constant 1/2 was multiplied into every term. The second pupil integrated correctly, but when substituting the limits wrote 1/2[4/11 - 4] = 1/2(-40/11) = -20/11. The 1/2 comes from (g(x))/2, so it belongs only to ∫₀² g(x) dx. It cannot multiply the -4, because that -4 comes from ∫₀² 2x dx, which was never halved. The pupil then put -20/11 back into the original integral as g(x) and integrated a second time, ending with -64/11. A definite integral is finished once the limits are substituted: the number you get is the answer, not a function to integrate again.

Markah yang hilang

Marks lost

Kesilapan 1: jawapan akhir betul secara kebetulan, tetapi markah bagi langkah pengamiran hilang kerana 2x tidak dikamirkan. Kesilapan 2: markah bagi langkah gantian dan jawapan akhir hilang, kerana 1/2 didarab dengan -4 dan kamiran itu diulang.

Mistake 1: the final answer is right by coincidence, but the mark for the integration step is lost because 2x was not integrated. Mistake 2: the marks for the substitution step and the final answer are lost, because the 1/2 was multiplied into the -4 and the integral was done again.

Semak semula langkah ini setiap kali anda menjawab soalan seperti ini.

Check this step again every time you answer a question like this.

Chegu Khairi menanda kerja ini setiap minggu

Chegu Khairi marks this every week

Kerja rumah ditanda pada hari yang sama dan dibincangkan dalam kelas berikutnya, jadi kesalahan sebegini dapat diperbetulkan semasa latihan dan bukan berlaku semasa peperiksaan.

Homework is marked the same day and discussed in the next class, so a mistake like this one gets corrected during practice rather than happening in the exam.

Tanya tentang kelas Ask about classes
Register for December 2026 School AddMaths Workshop WhatsApp Chegu Khairi for Class / School Holiday Workshop